The Bottleneck Is You: When Rewards for Doing Become the Problem

This post is part of the “Where Leadership Gets Hard” series—based on over 25 years of coaching leaders through real problems. No theory, just what I’ve seen work.

Here’s a pattern I’ve seen more times than any other in my coaching practice.

Someone gets good at the work. Really good. They estimate the job better than anyone, or they run the shift smoother than anyone, or they close the client others can’t close. The company notices. They get promoted. They get promoted again. Eventually they’re running a team of people who do the work they used to do themselves.

And that’s when things start to go sideways.

Because the behaviors that got them promoted — personal responsiveness, mastery of detail, willingness to jump in — are now the behaviors that are keeping their team from growing. The leader is still the person answering the customer’s call on Saturday morning. They’re still the person fixing the problem at 10 p.m. They’re still the person who knows the answer.

And the team has quietly learned: we don’t need to figure it out, because the boss will.

One department manager I worked with — a good one, genuinely cared about his people — told me he noticed his project managers had stopped even trying to handle weekend escalations.

“With his PMs, if it’s Saturday morning and the customer calls and asks for help, the PMs don’t even bother, because he jumps in. They were actually working on it, but he jumps in too early. He doesn’t want the customer to have a bad experience.”

— Department manager describing his own pattern

When I asked him what fear was driving the jumping in, he said it plainly: “Fear that it will be viewed that I’m not doing my job. Fear of failure.”

That’s the hidden engine. It’s not that the leader doesn’t know they should delegate. Every leader knows they should delegate. It’s that the feeling of watching someone else do the work slower, differently, or badly is more than they can bear. Their identity is bound up in the doing. Letting go feels like disappearing.

What the team learns when you jump in

When you intervene before your team has had a chance to solve the problem, you’re not protecting the customer. You’re teaching three lessons the team will not forget.

One: your initiative is optional, because the boss will take it back.

Two: your judgment is not trusted, because it’s being overridden.

Three: the path to promotion is not actually through mastering this work — because the boss is still doing this work.

Over time, you get the team you’ve trained. Dependent. Tentative. Reactive. And then you stand there wondering why they can’t seem to step up.

The move

The move isn’t to stop caring about the customer; it’s to widen the circle of people who can care about the customer. Before you jump in, ask yourself: is this the kind of problem my team needs to solve once in order to never need me to solve it again? If yes, your job is to step back.

The anxiety won’t feel good. Do it anyway. That anxiety is the sound of your team becoming able.

Where are you the bottleneck in your own organization right now — and what are you afraid would happen if you stepped out of the way?

You Might Also Like…

October 2026 Leadership Development Digest

October 2026 Leadership Development Digest

There’s a lot of giving when you’re a leader. You’re giving lots of direction, coaching, clarifying, explaining, feedback, and course-correcting. All of that output can make a leader exhausted, deenergized, and spent. When you’re doing it day after day after day, and...

Making It Up As We Go

Making It Up As We Go

This post is part of the “Where Leadership Gets Hard” series—based on over 25 years of coaching leaders through real problems. No theory, just what I’ve seen work. I've noticed a sentence that comes up in my coaching sessions with leaders at fast-growing companies. It...

The Best Part Of Leading

The Best Part Of Leading

Leadership is hard work. It takes making accurate decisions based often on inaccurate or incomplete data. It requires bringing about change and contending with the resistance that it prompts. It's caring about those you lead, but remaining objective enough not to get...